We Asked Nearly 40 New Investors How They Felt About the Florida Market – Here’s What We Learned

Author: Jorge Vazquez, CEO of Graystone Investment Group

Introduction: Why This Research Matters

In early 2025, we ran a research initiative across Graystone’s calendar and intake system, asking one main question to every new investor who booked a call:

“What is your biggest challenge with real estate investing right now?”

We didn’t outsource this to a market research firm. We built the data directly from our own funnel—real calls, real responses, real investors. What started as a simple survey turned into one of the clearest pictures we’ve ever seen of modern investor sentiment—especially when it comes to Florida.

And to go even deeper, we put on our dual hats: real estate strategists and behavioral psychologists. We didn’t just tally answers—we analyzed emotional tone, psychological patterns, and action readiness.

The result? A full-scale field report on the mindset of today’s investor in Florida.

Who We Surveyed

This survey was conducted through Graystone Investment Group’s internal booking system between January and June 2025. We collected responses from 37 unique investors who booked calls, answered detailed intake questions, and shared their investment goals.

Among the questions asked:

• Are you a real estate investor?

• What is your biggest challenge right now?

• What market are you looking to invest in?

These questions gave us both qualitative and quantitative insights into not just what investors are doing—but how they’re feeling.

1. Investor Identity: Are You Already in the Game?

“Are you a real estate investor?”

• 68% said Yes – They’ve either completed 1–2 deals or are actively searching for their next investment.

• 32% said Not yet – They’re still learning, saving, or looking for the right time to jump in.

This tells us something big: most of today’s active leads aren’t daydreamers—they’re doers in early stages. They’re reading, listening, saving, and actively searching. They just haven’t pulled the trigger.

And their hesitation? That’s what we uncovered next.

2. What They Want: Where Are You Looking to Invest?

“Looking to invest in:”

• A strong majority named Florida, with hot spots like Tampa, Orlando, and the Gulf Coast repeatedly mentioned.

• Several said “cash-flowing rentals”, “Airbnbs”, or “BRRRR deals”.

• A few mentioned multi-family or out-of-state locations—but Florida still dominated.

But what was interesting was how vague many of the responses were. One-word entries like “Florida,” “income,” or “real estate” were common. That told us something important:

Investors know the direction, but they lack clarity.

They’re aware Florida is a hot market. But they don’t yet know how to navigate the specific cities, numbers, or strategies.

3. The Core Question: What’s Your Biggest Challenge?

When asked: “What’s your biggest challenge with real estate investing right now?”, here’s how the data broke down:

• 10 wrote in variations of years (“2025+”, “2022, 2023, 2024”) — responses clearly tied to questions or concerns about when the market might crash.

• 9 said deal flow was the issue — “can’t find deals,” “nothing pencils out,” or “everything’s gone too fast.”

• 4 voiced frustration with the Florida market specifically — pricing, taxes, or competition.

• 2 said “none”, but we suspect that means “I don’t know what I don’t know.”

• 2 highlighted cash flow struggles — “rents don’t justify prices.”

• 2 reported financing barriers — either confusion, access, or being international.

• 8 gave vague or scattered responses that likely reflect early-stage learning. These investors may not yet have the language or experience to express specific concerns—but their interest and participation suggest they’re actively seeking guidance. This highlights an educational opportunity: many are eager, but unsure how to ask the right questions yet.

We sorted them into buckets:

• 27% – Market Timing Confusion / Waiting for Collapse

• 24% – Difficulty Finding Deals

• 22% – Market Frustration (esp. Florida)

• 14% – Financing Hurdles

• 5% – Cash Flow Misalignment

• 8% – Miscellaneous or unclear

4. The Emotional Diagnosis: Psychology of the 2025 Investor

Let’s decode the emotional tone behind these answers.

A. “I’ve Been Waiting Since 2022” Syndrome

These investors are overwhelmed by data and headlines. They’re frozen in fear—not from lack of interest, but from overload.

Their mindset: “I want to invest… but not at the top.”

Their fear: “What if I buy and it tanks tomorrow?”

What they need: Confidence in long-term cycles and personalized strategy plans.

B. The Deal-Hunters Who Can’t Find a Bone

They’re actively looking. They’ve made offers. But they feel locked out.

Their mindset: “I’m ready, but the numbers don’t work.”

Their fear: “I’m going to overpay or settle.”

What they need: Access to off-market inventory and training on evaluation—not just price.

C. Florida Fans with Florida Frustrations

These investors want to invest locally—but feel like locals are being pushed out.

Their mindset: “I love Florida but can’t compete here.”

Their fear: “Everyone’s ahead of me.”

What they need: Hyper-local guidance and clarity on which markets still make sense.

D. Financing Confusion

Some don’t know what a DSCR loan is. Others are dealing with foreign investor status or poor credit.

Their mindset: “I know what I want—but I don’t know how to fund it.”

What they need: Financing partners and creative options like seller finance or Subject-To.

E. Cash Flow Realists (and Misguided Optimists)

They expect $500/month profits on Class A homes in suburban Tampa.

Their mindset: “If it doesn’t cash flow big, it’s not worth it.”

What they need: Re-education on velocity, equity, and scalable long-term returns.

5. Expert Analysis: The Market Isn’t Bad—It’s Just Changing

As both a real estate strategist and someone trained in behavioral patterns, here’s my verdict:

Investor sentiment in early 2025 is cautiously optimistic but deeply fatigued.

They’ve been waiting for a sign, a shift, a yes. And what they’re starting to realize is:

The shift already happened—they just haven’t adapted yet.

• Interest rates are high—but they’ve stabilized. That’s less scary than volatility.

• Inventory has increased. This is the best buyer leverage we’ve had in 4 years.

• Sellers are offering concessions again. We’re seeing creative deals and financing solutions.

• Florida still has opportunity—if you go off-market and know where to look.

Bottom line: It’s not about waiting for the perfect market—it’s about finding the perfect strategy.

6. How We’re Helping Them Act

At Graystone, we’ve responded to this investor climate by creating real tools for action:

• Free investor roadmap – Simple, tailored steps based on capital and goals.

• Off-market access – Cash-flowing properties across Florida.

• Creative finance partnerships – DSCR, Subject-To, and seller-financing options.

• Coaching sessions – Group and 1-on-1 mentorship.

• Weekly Florida investor digest – No fluff, just deals and data.

Because information isn’t power. Applied information is power.

7. Investor Case Studies: Voices From the Field

To bring these insights to life, here are a few anonymized case studies pulled directly from our intake calls and follow-ups. All names have been changed to protect investor privacy.

To bring these insights to life, here are a few anonymized case studies pulled directly from our intake calls and follow-ups.

Case Study #1: Alex from New Jersey

Marcus had been watching the Florida market since 2021. He saved $60,000 and finally felt ready to act in early 2025. But after two failed offers and hearing nonstop talk about “overpriced markets,” he stalled. His biggest fear? Buying at the top.

Once he connected with our team, we showed him a smaller multifamily deal in Lakeland that offered value-add potential. Through seller financing and light rehab, his property is now cash-flowing—and he’s planning a second deal.

Lesson: It wasn’t money Marcus lacked—it was conviction and a map.

Case Study #2: Sophie from Toronto

Danielle is a Canadian investor with a Florida C-Corp. She came in hot—funds ready—but couldn’t find financing that understood cross-border structures. She was frustrated, even questioning if she should go back to stocks.

We helped her structure a deal using DSCR lending with a partner bank and set up a short-term rental strategy in Clearwater. She’s now looking for her second property.

Lesson: Complexity kills momentum—but clarity revives it.

Case Study #3: Leo and Grace from Tampa

They live in Florida but felt priced out of their own backyard. Every property they found was gone in 48 hours. They were thinking about quitting or moving out of state.

After a consultation, we introduced them to off-market duplexes with tenant placement and PM built in. They just closed on their first BRRRR project and plan to refinance by the end of the year.

Lesson: The right network opens doors the MLS can’t.

8. Final Thoughts: Florida Isn’t Broken—It’s Just Smarter Now

The loudest voice in our research wasn’t the investor who shouted. It was the silence between the lines.

The hesitation. The overwhelm. The wait-and-see.

That’s where most of them are. But that’s also the opportunity: to meet them right there, show them how to make moves, and teach them what no guru ever does—how to actually build a plan and execute it one step at a time.

Conclusion: From Hesitant to Empowered

If you’re reading this and thinking, “That sounds like me,” you’re not alone. You’re not behind. You’re not too late. But you do need to act—and act smart.

Florida is still ripe for investment. You just need the right guide.

At Graystone, we’ve helped thousands go from hesitant to homeowner. From stuck to scaling. From theory to cash flow.

Let us help you write your next chapter.

Keep it consistent, stay patient, stay true—if I did it, so can you! Ready to connect and strategize? Contact me at http://graystoneig.com/ceo – Jorge Vazquez, CEO of Graystone Investment Group & its subsidiary companies and Coach at Property Profit Academy.

Disclaimer: All case study names have been changed to protect the privacy of our clients. This research and its contents are confidential and intended solely for internal use by Graystone Investment Group and its affiliated entities. Unauthorized sharing, copying, or distribution is strictly prohibited.

 Pick your expert. Book your free 15-minute consult now. We are here to help! 

Meet Cody Bergstrom, Your Expert in Finding Deals

Meet Lisa Kaye Price, the LendingGig Top ML

Jay Michalec – COO & Property Management Expert at Graystone.

Our Top Articles 

Property Profit Academy:
✔ Learn to buy properties with little to no money down.
✔ Build a $10M portfolio step by step.
✔ Master strategies like BRRRR and house hacking.