How Does a Property Flipper Make a Profit in 2025?

How Does a Property Flipper Make a Profit in 2025?
By Jorge Vazquez, CEO of Graystone Investment Group

It’s been four years since I first wrote that viral Forbes piece, and I still get questions about it all the time: “Do you still believe the profit comes from the discount, not the rehab?” My answer? Absolutely. In fact, it matters more now than ever.

Let me walk you through it, like you’re sitting in my office, maybe with a cafecito in hand, trying to figure out your first flip—or your fiftieth. The game hasn’t changed. But the market? Oh, it’s evolved. And if you’re not buying smart, no amount of high-end tile or quartz countertops is going to save your margins.

The Myth That Rehab Makes You Rich

Back when I wrote the original article, I told a story about Gary—a new investor who came in ready to flip houses like he was auditioning for HGTV. He had a six-figure inheritance, spreadsheets of rehab estimates, and a vision of polished floors and open-concept kitchens.

But what Gary didn’t realize—what most people don’t—is that rehabs don’t create profit. Discounts do.

Look, I love a good before-and-after transformation as much as anyone. But those moments you see on TV, where someone knocks down a wall and suddenly the house is worth $100K more? Yeah, that’s not how this works. The real money is made when you buy the property, not when you tear down drywall.

And that truth is even louder in 2025.

Why 2025 is a Tougher Market

Let’s be real. The last couple of years have not been as friendly to flippers as the 2021-2022 wave. Interest rates shot up, renovation costs spiked, and buyers became pickier. That frothy appreciation? Gone. You can’t rely on the market to bail you out of a bad buy anymore.

In Florida—where I operate—it’s still competitive. Inventory’s low, but that doesn’t mean prices are low. And the biggest trap I see flippers fall into is overpaying for a deal just because the kitchen has “potential.”

By mid-2025, the average flip profit has shrunk to about 25% ROI. That’s down from the glory days of 40-50%. The only ones still thriving are the ones who are disciplined. Who buy ugly houses in the right zip codes, do just enough rehab to meet the comps, and move fast.

Builders Aren’t Magicians Either

Another thing I explained to Gary back then (and it still holds true today): even builders don’t magically make money from building. They make money by buying land cheap and building at scale. They’re like Costco—they buy land by the acre, chop it up, and sell by the lot. Or like a bar that buys whiskey by the barrel and sells it by the shot.

So no, profit doesn’t come from slapping new construction on any old lot. It comes from cost control and strategic buying. Same as flipping.

Rehab: Necessary Evil or Strategic Advantage?

Now, don’t get me wrong—rehab matters. It’s how you realize the profit that was baked in at purchase. But it’s not where you create profit.

You know what adds real value? Fixing the stuff buyers are scared to touch. Roof leaks. Electrical issues. Old plumbing. If you solve a problem that most homebuyers can’t fix themselves, you create leverage. But if you’re just adding marble floors in a neighborhood that comps out at laminate prices, you’re throwing money out the window.

I’ve seen investors blow $30K on upgrades that added maybe $10K in value. And then they wonder why the numbers don’t work.

Here’s a reality check: most renovations don’t give you dollar-for-dollar returns. Install a $10K kitchen? You might only see $7K of that reflected in appraised value. Add a $3K stove? Maybe it bumps the value $1,500—if you’re lucky.

The market is smart. It rewards function, not flash. And if you go overboard, it assumes you’re doing it for your own enjoyment, not resale.

It’s Psychological

That brings me to a point I made in the article that I think is even more true now: there’s a psychological payoff to rehabbing. Just like someone might drop $200 on dinner at a steakhouse for the experience, not the nutrition, homeowners invest in renovations for joy.

But as flippers? We can’t afford to fall in love with the finishes. We’re not creating our forever home. We’re building a product that needs to sell—fast—and appraise well. So keep it clean, keep it functional, and save the velvet wallpaper for someone else’s Pinterest board.

Florida in 2025: What’s Changed?

Let’s zoom in on Florida for a second. This market is hot, but not in the same way it was in 2021. Back then, everything sold in hours. Now? You better know your comps. You better understand appraisal risk. You better not assume every buyer is going to waive inspection.

The buyers out there in 2025? They’re cautious. They want value. And they’re not overpaying for a flip that’s been over-improved. They can smell desperation, and if your margins depend on the perfect buyer paying the perfect price… you’re cooked.

We’re seeing strong flips still happening in certain pockets—Seminole Heights, Allapattah, Riverside—but only when the investor bought low and rehabbed smart.

What Flippers Get Wrong in 2025

Let me tell you what I see over and over again:

• Investors buy too high, hoping the market will keep going up. It won’t.

• They rehab too fancy, assuming it’ll “wow” the appraiser. It won’t.

• They hold too long, hoping to get lucky. They don’t.

Meanwhile, the ones who are killing it? They’ve got this formula down:

Buy it ugly. Buy it cheap. Fix what matters. Price it right. Sell fast.

TV Still Gets It Wrong

Four years later, the flipping shows still haven’t changed. It’s all about demo day, the big reveal, the crying couple. But none of that shows the hardest part—negotiating the purchase, managing the crew, sticking to budget, navigating inspections, handling lenders.

Entertainment sells the sledgehammer. Real profit comes from spreadsheets.

The Lesson That Keeps Paying Off

Gary, the investor from the article? He listened. He bought at a deep discount, kept his rehab realistic, and sold for a healthy profit. He didn’t try to be Chip and Joanna. He tried to be profitable.

And that’s still the game today.

Whether you’re flipping in Tampa, Orlando, or somewhere in the Panhandle, the rules haven’t changed:

• Make your money on the buy.

• Don’t overspend on rehab.

• Understand what your market will bear.

• Don’t fall in love with the house—fall in love with the numbers.

Final Thoughts

The market may change. Interest rates may rise. Buyer behavior may shift. But the math? That doesn’t lie. In 2025, if you want to make money flipping houses, you’ve got to buy right, build smart, and sell fast.

So yes, four years later, I still stand by every word I wrote in that article. And if anything, it matters more now than ever. The market’s gotten tighter. The buyers are more informed. The profits are smaller. And the only way to win this game is to play it smart.

Keep it consistent, stay patient, stay true—if I did it, so can you. This is Jorge Vazquez, CEO of Graystone Investment Group and all our amazing companies, and Coach at Property Profit Academy. Thanks for tuning in—until the next article, take care and keep building!

If you’d like to connect directly with me, feel free to book a time here: https://graystoneig.com/ceo.

P.S. If you missed the original article that started it all, check it out here:
https://www.forbes.com/councils/forbesbusinesscouncil/2021/11/05/how-does-a-property-flipper-make-a-profit/

 Pick your expert. Book your free 15-minute consult now. We are here to help! 

Meet Cody Bergstrom, Your Expert in Finding Deals

Meet Lisa Kaye Price, the LendingGig Top ML

Jay Michalec – COO & Property Management Expert at Graystone.

Our Top Articles 

Property Profit Academy:
✔ Learn to buy properties with little to no money down.
✔ Build a $10M portfolio step by step.
✔ Master strategies like BRRRR and house hacking.