Insurance Rates Haven’t Gone Up Because of Hurricanes: A Real Estate Insider’s Perspective

Insurance Rates Haven’t Gone Up Because of Hurricanes: A Real Estate Insider’s Perspective

By Jorge Vazquez, CEO of Graystone Investment Group

For years, we’ve heard the same narrative: insurance rates are skyrocketing because of hurricanes. News headlines flash images of destructive storms, and the blame for rising premiums is immediately pinned on Mother Nature. But as someone who has been deeply embedded in Florida’s real estate market for over two decades, I can confidently tell you that this assumption is far from the truth. Insurance rates have indeed gone up, but hurricanes aren’t the primary cause.

Let me break down why this issue is far more complex than simply blaming natural disasters. In fact, the real culprit behind rising insurance premiums is something that many property owners and investors overlook: fraud and litigation abuse.

The Real Culprit: Insurance Fraud and Litigation

Here’s a fact that’s not often discussed: Florida accounts for 76% of all homeowners’ insurance lawsuits in the U.S., despite only having about 8% of the nation’s homeowners’ claims​

​

. When you hear a statistic like that, it’s hard to ignore the massive role that fraud and litigation abuse play in the insurance landscape. You see, Florida’s laws used to be a free-for-all for lawyers who knew how to game the system.

Before the 2022 insurance reform, homeowners and their attorneys could easily file claims against insurance companies—even for minor or questionable damage. They’d drag the insurers into court, running up legal fees in the process. Insurance companies would often settle just to avoid the lengthy legal battle. And guess what? All those costs eventually trickled down to you—the policyholders— in the form of higher premiums.

I’ve experienced this firsthand. Not long ago, I could file a claim on my rental properties even for minor damages and get a pretty hefty payout. It wasn’t always fair, but it was legal. A few fence pieces blew off? Claim it. Some shingles were displaced? Claim it. And with the right lawyer, you could twist the system in your favor.

In my case, my properties were barely touched by storms, but back then, it was the lawyer’s playground. The law made it easy to sue insurance companies. A lawyer would tell me, “Jorge, the insurance company will just settle—they don’t want the hassle of court.” And more often than not, they did. This was an industry-wide issue. Everyone was doing it, and insurance companies were bleeding money not from paying out genuine hurricane-related claims but from paying out settlements for fraudulent or exaggerated claims.

Why Hurricanes Are the Scapegoat

So why do hurricanes get blamed? Because it’s easier to tell a story about natural disasters. It stirs up emotions, grabs headlines, and makes for a neat explanation when your insurance bill jumps by 25%. But hurricanes aren’t the main cause of the rising costs. Yes, they contribute, but their impact is minor compared to what’s happening behind the scenes.

Let’s take the 2022 hurricane season as an example. Yes, Florida was hit, but most of the damage from hurricanes comes from flooding, which isn’t even covered by standard homeowners’ insurance policies. If you’re in a flood zone, you need separate flood insurance, and yes, that cost is going up, but it’s a different story.

The truth is that while hurricanes create a significant amount of damage, they don’t directly correlate with the insurance price increases we’re seeing year after year. It’s the legal battles, not the storms, that are making insurers pull out of Florida or hike up their premiums.

The Legal Changes of 2022: A Step in the Right Direction

In May 2022, Governor Ron DeSantis signed a law (SB-2D) aimed at addressing these issues​

. The bill made it harder for attorneys to file frivolous lawsuits against insurance companies. It eliminated the “one-way attorney fees” rule, which allowed homeowners to get their legal fees covered by insurers if they won a lawsuit. Opportunistic lawyers had heavily abused this rule, and its removal is a game-changer.

The new law also introduced a requirement that homeowners must prove a breach of contract before they can sue an insurer for bad faith​

. These changes are crucial for reducing the legal battles driving up costs. However, it will take time for these reforms to have a noticeable impact on premiums. The damage done by years of rampant litigation can’t be undone overnight.

My Own Experience: From Filing Claims to a New Reality

Let me share a personal story to illustrate how these changes have impacted me as an investor. A few years ago, I filed claims on two of my rental properties in Tampa—2210 and 2807. One had a few pieces of fence knocked down, and the other had some minor damage to the front yard. Under the old system, I knew I could get a decent payout, even if the damage didn’t really warrant it. My lawyer would have filed a claim, the insurance company would have settled, and I’d walk away with more money than the repair actually cost me.

Fast forward to today, and things are different. After the reforms, I filed a claim for similar damage, and the insurance company didn’t budge. They no longer have the legal pressure to settle out of fear of a lawsuit. They simply denied the claim. And guess what? I couldn’t do much about it because the new laws are in place to prevent the kind of exploitation that was rampant before.

I’m not going to lie—it stings. But as someone who’s been on both sides of this issue, I understand why the reforms were necessary. The system had become unsustainable, and as much as it’s inconvenient for individual property owners, it’s better for the market as a whole.

The Future of Insurance in Florida

With these legal changes, Florida’s insurance market is slowly stabilizing. Insurance companies are less afraid of being sued into bankruptcy, and new players are entering the market. This will eventually lead to more competition and, hopefully, lower premiums in the future.

But there’s another side to this story: climate change and rising sea levels. While fraud and litigation have been the primary drivers of insurance hikes, the future of the market will depend heavily on how well we can adapt to the changing environment. Coastal properties are going to face more risks, and we need to be prepared for that.

Yet, even in the face of these challenges, we shouldn’t let hurricanes be the scapegoat for a broken system. The real solution lies in addressing the deeper issues—fraud, litigation, and ensuring that property owners take a more proactive approach to risk management.

Conclusion: A Balanced Approach (Extended)

As a real estate investor and CEO of Graystone Investment Group, I’ve learned that the most important thing you can do is educate yourself. Don’t blindly accept that hurricanes are to blame for every insurance rate increase. Look deeper, understand the legal and financial dynamics at play, and make informed decisions about where you invest and how you protect your properties.

We’ve already seen how the 2022 reforms are starting to change the game. The days of exploiting insurance companies are coming to an end, and that’s a good thing for everyone—except maybe the lawyers. The next time your insurance premium goes up, take a moment to consider the real reasons behind it. Hurricanes may grab the headlines, but fraud, litigation, and outdated laws are the real storm we’ve been fighting.

From sinkhole fraud, which plagued the industry years ago, to today’s insurance lawsuit fraud, the exploitation of these systems has created instability in Florida’s insurance market for decades. But as the legal system cracks down on these practices, we are witnessing the slow death of this abuse. The new laws, combined with the upcoming infrastructure investments and reforms, will eventually stabilize insurance prices in the future.

As property owners and investors, we need to be ready. Be bold. Don’t think short-term. Look long-term. In real estate, the winners are those who stay ahead of the curve, understanding that markets fluctuate but will always correct themselves with the right policies in place. The future of Florida’s property market is bright—as long as we focus on building stronger, smarter, and more sustainable investments.

Ready to take your real estate investing knowledge to the next level? Join our Property Profit Academy today! https://www.propertyprofitacademy.com

Vanessa has over 23 years of business management experience and has been in the real estate industry since 2018. She and her team prioritize serving clients and finding the right financing options. Schedule a meeting with Vanessa: https://graystoneig.com/vanessa

My team and I have over 20 years of experience in real estate. We have strong relationships with wholesalers, probate lawyers, sellers, and others in Florida. I aim to align your investments with your vision and deliver exceptional results. Contact Vanessa to schedule a meeting: https://graystoneig.com/cody

Hello, I’m Marylyn Patankar, the Field Manager and New Client Ambassador at Graystone Property Management. I educate investors about our perks, onboard new landlord investors, and manage on-site operations. Schedule a meeting with me here: https://graystoneig.com/marylyn