Questions to Ask Real Estate Agent When Selling

What Questions to Ask Your Real Estate Agent When Selling Your Property

Selling your property—whether it’s your family home or an investment property—is a significant step. After managing hundreds of agents and completing thousands of transactions as a licensed broker, I’ve seen firsthand how the right real estate agent can make all the difference. I’ve worked across retail and wholesale markets for investors, and one thing is clear: your agent needs to align with your goals, whether you’re looking for maximum profit or a fast, stress-free sale.

The key to finding the perfect agent? Asking the right questions. Here’s a guide for residential sellers and investors, plus insights into how agents should calculate ROI (Return on Investment) and cap rate to maximize your outcomes.

Questions for Residential Sellers

1. How Well Do You Know My Neighborhood?

Local expertise is critical. You need an agent who understands the market trends in your area and knows what buyers are looking for. Ask:

  • Have you sold homes in this area before?
  • What are the recent trends in local home sales?
  • What features of my home are most appealing to buyers in this market?

Why This Matters: The best agents know how to highlight what makes your neighborhood special, whether it’s top-rated schools or proximity to the hottest local spots.

2. How Will You Market My Home?

A strong marketing plan separates an average agent from a stellar one. Find out:

  • Will you hire professional photographers or videographers?
  • Do you offer virtual tours or 3D walkthroughs?
  • Which platforms will feature my property (e.g., MLS, Zillow, social media)?
  • How will you attract potential buyers to my home?

Why This Matters: I’ve learned that high-quality marketing can make or break a sale. Every property should be presented like a luxury listing, even if it’s a modest starter home.

3. How Will You Determine My Listing Price?

Pricing your property correctly is critical. An experienced agent uses data-driven strategies. Ask:

  • How do you calculate the listing price?
  • Will you provide a comparative market analysis (CMA)?
  • What’s your plan if the property doesn’t generate offers quickly?

Why This Matters: Overpricing discourages buyers, while underpricing leaves money on the table. A great agent knows how to hit that sweet spot.

4. What Should I Do to Prepare My Home for Sale?

A well-prepared home sells faster and for a better price. Ask:

  • Do I need to make repairs or updates?
  • Should I consider staging my home?
  • How can I boost curb appeal on a budget?

Why This Matters: From my experience, even small tweaks—like fresh paint or decluttering—can significantly improve your sale price.

5. How Will You Handle Showings and Offers?

Showings and offers can be stressful without proper management. Ask:

  • How will you schedule and coordinate showings?
  • Will you pre-qualify buyers to ensure they’re serious?
  • How will you present and negotiate offers on my behalf?

Why This Matters: An organized agent keeps the process smooth and professional, helping you avoid unnecessary stress.

6. What Happens After I Accept an Offer?

The sale isn’t over when the buyer says “yes.” You need a plan for the closing process. Ask:

  • How will you help with inspections and appraisals?
  • What’s your role in the closing process?
  • How do you handle unexpected issues, like failed inspections or financing problems?

Why This Matters: I’ve seen deals fall apart due to poor communication or missed deadlines. A seasoned agent ensures the process stays on track.

Questions for Investors Selling Property

Selling an investment property is a different ballgame. As someone who has worked with countless investors, I know your agent needs to understand numbers, tax implications, and market positioning.

1. Do You Work With Investors Regularly?

Not all agents are equipped to handle investment sales. Ask:

  • What percentage of your clients are investors?
  • Can you provide examples of investment properties you’ve sold?
  • How do you tailor your approach for investment properties?

Why This Matters: Investors need agents who understand cash flow, cap rates, and ROI, not just pretty pictures and emotional appeals.

2. How Will You Market My Investment Property?

Investment properties often target a different audience than residential homes. Ask:

  • Will you market to other investors, owner-occupiers, or both?
  • Can you highlight the property’s financials (e.g., rent roll, expenses, income)?
  • How will you position the property to attract serious buyers?

Why This Matters: A good agent makes your property irresistible by focusing on its income potential and long-term value.

3. Can You Analyze My Property’s Value Using ROI and Cap Rate?

Every investor understands the importance of these metrics. Ask:

  • Will you calculate ROI and cap rate for my property?
  • How will you compare my property’s profitability to others in the market?
  • Can you provide a clear analysis to present to potential buyers?

Why This Matters: In my experience, an agent who knows how to run the numbers is invaluable. These calculations help attract buyers who care about the bottom line.

4. Are You Familiar With 1031 Exchanges and Tax Implications?

Tax planning is a big part of selling investment properties. Ask:

  • Can you advise on 1031 exchanges?
  • How will selling this property affect my tax liability?
  • Do you have connections with tax professionals for more complex questions?

Why This Matters: A knowledgeable agent can guide you through the tax implications of your sale, helping you avoid costly mistakes.

5. What’s Your Plan if My Property Doesn’t Sell Quickly?

Investment properties can sometimes take longer to sell. Ask:

  • How will you adjust the marketing strategy if the property doesn’t sell?
  • Will you recommend price changes or new buyer targets?

Why This Matters: I’ve seen agents lose momentum when properties linger on the market. A great agent always has a backup plan.

The Importance of ROI and Cap Rate

An agent working with investors must know how to calculate and explain key financial metrics.

How to Calculate ROI (Return on Investment)

ROI=Net ProfitTotal Investment×100\text{ROI} = \frac{\text{Net Profit}}{\text{Total Investment}} \times 100

  • Net Profit: Sale price minus purchase price, closing costs, and other expenses.
  • Total Investment: The total amount you’ve spent, including purchase price, renovations, and carrying costs.

Example:
You bought a property for $200,000, spent $50,000 on renovations, and sold it for $300,000. Your net profit is $50,000. ROI = 50,000250,000×100=20%\frac{50,000}{250,000} \times 100 = 20\%.

How to Calculate Cap Rate (Capitalization Rate)

Cap Rate=Net Operating Income (NOI)Current Market Value×100\text{Cap Rate} = \frac{\text{Net Operating Income (NOI)}}{\text{Current Market Value}} \times 100

  • NOI: Annual income minus operating expenses (not including mortgage payments).
  • Market Value: The property’s sale price or appraised value.

Example:
Your rental property generates $24,000 in income, with $6,000 in operating expenses. NOI = $18,000. If the property is worth $300,000, Cap Rate = 18,000300,000×100=6%\frac{18,000}{300,000} \times 100 = 6\%.

Why These Metrics Matter: An agent who understands ROI and cap rate can position your property as a smart investment, attracting the right buyers and maximizing your profit.

Final Thoughts: Choose the Right Agent for Your Needs

After managing hundreds of agents and thousands of transactions, I can confidently say that asking the right questions is your first step toward a successful sale. Residential sellers need an agent who can market their home to the right audience, while investors require someone who speaks their language and understands the numbers.

By vetting your agent with the questions above, you’ll ensure they’re the right fit for your goals, whether you’re selling a cozy family home or a high-performing rental property.

OUR BEST ARTICLES

Use code ZEROTO10M for your FREE first month at Property Profit Academy and:
✔ Learn to buy properties with little to no money down.
✔ Build a $10M portfolio step by step.
✔ Master strategies like BRRRR and house hacking.

🚀 BONUS: Join in 24 hours for a private coaching session with me, Jorge Vazquez.

💻 Start Now: http://propertyprofitacademy.com

Keep it consistent, stay patient, stay true—if I did it, so can you! Ready to learn? Let me guide you at propertyprofitacademy.com – Jorge Vazquez, CEO of Graystone Investment Group & Coach at Property Profit Academy.